Film-book
Daily Updates via Email

Film-book
Film-book

Mar 13, 2009

Film Review: Watchmen

watchmen-ver2-posterWatchmen is a comic book adaptation set in a alternate reality where world history has turned out differently than in our own. Many of the heroes in this film are as bad as or worse than the criminals they protect society from. These heroes are broken, conflicted, damaged individuals, either by their long careers of fighting crime or from personality flaws they brought to the table at the outset. Superhero in Watchmen can easily be construed as an acronym for human being. In most popcorn superhero films, events within the film break over and around the superhero like creamy ocean water against a rocky bank before reseeding again e.g. Spiderman and Superman. In Watchmen, the wave of blood and violence soaks into the fibers of its superheroes, including sociopath Watchmen Rorschach / Walter Korvach (Jackie Earle Haley), misanthrope Watchmen The Comedian / Edward Blake (Jeffrey Dean Morgan), and former Watchmen Silk Spectre I / Sally Jupiter (Carla Gugino). Incidents in the past shape the superhero of the present. This is true of The Dark Knight, Hancock, Darkman, etc. Instead of forging an impeccable, infallible symbol of law, order and righteousness; this gutter overflow in New York City corrupts its bearers, their view of the world and its inhabitants, even though their occupation is bringing lawbreakers to justice. “What happened to us? What happened to the American Dream?”, Nite Owl II / Daniel Dreiberg (Patrick Wilson) asks. The Comedian responds: “What happened to the American Dream? It came true. You’re looking at it.”

The Comedian was not referring to the riot he had just dispersed with his shot gun and grenade launcher, he was speaking of America as a country. Second, he was alluding to absolute power, the kind he possessed (or thought he possessed) and America’s. Because of Dr. Manhattan / Dr. Jon Osterman (Billy Crudup)’s presence, America had become hegemony. The American government had grown dependent on Dr. Manhattan, the threat of his infinite abilities against foreign powers and what he could do for the country. Even with his infinite abilities, making him in many respects like Leto Atreides II in Dune: God Emperor, Dr. Manhattan had not succeeded in pacifying the known universe. The threat of nuclear holocaust was ever present. Third, The Comedian is also referring to other superheroes. They act as though they are above the law because in many respects they are. They get away with terrible acts. Nite Owl I / Hollis Mason (Stephen McHattie) referred to this in his book “Under the Hood” as The Age of the Superhero or something to that effect after Dr. Manhattan splatters a trio of Wise Guys in front of their squeezes. Instead of this age being one of light, it is one of escalating darkness with severe social consequences.

Though Watchmen is first about discovering who killed The Comedian and later about unraveling a larger conspiracy behind a masked killer plot, the film is foremost about the people involved and whom The Comedian’s death directly and indirectly affects. The most prominent individual amongst this group is Rorschach, the sole person from the Watchmen team motivated to investigate The Comedian’s death. “An attack against one of us is an attack against all of us,” Rorschach says while trying to recruit Nite Owl II to the cause. This coercion is necessary because The Comedian was not liked by most people because of certain antisocial personality traits and events in the past. It is Rorschach, arguably the most twisted Watchmen next to The Comedian, who propels the case forward. There is an old saying: “When you dance with the devil, you don’t change the devil, the devil changes you.” When applied to Rorschach, this is true to a devastating degree as the viewer bares witness to it in a flashback scene involving a kidnapped girl and a psychopath. Though the scene was not translated in its entirety from its source material, the adaptation served the same commencement purpose.

When looked upon as a comic book adaptation, Watchmen is probably one of the finest, visually, completely eclipsing the Spiderman franchise, X-Men 1, X-Men 3, Daredevil, Elektra, The Punisher films and a host of others. There is something to be said about the way Ang Lee’s Hulk is edited. To date, the viewer most-likely has not seen a film edited more like a comic book than that film.

Editorial presentation aside, the “Nostalgia” of the Watchmen heritage was captured with exceptional care in Watchmen. You need only view the film decadent opening credit sequence, created by yU+Co and accompanied by Bob Dylan’s “Times They Are A-Changin”, for credence to this statement. Watchmen has hands down the best opening montage the viewer may have ever seen for a superhero movie and for that matter any movie. Snyder uses his camera to capture iconic images from Alan Moore’s 12-part comic series but also, by accident or ingenious design, the comic book industry’s past as well. Comic book and superhero film fans will be enthralled by what they see during this section of the film. You are not just seeing the roots of the current Watchmen team, the Minutemen, but the foundation of the comic book industry during the era of the Watchmen’s original publication. It is in the costumes they are wearing, the way the shots are framed, and how those shots are slowly animated. It is in these moments, at the very inception of the story and film, that Zack Snyder demonstrates the depths of his directorial prowess, talent and that the film that follows will be visually appealing. Speaking of visual appeal, no confrontation in Watchmen has a better mise en scène than the one at the beginning of the film involving The Comedian and his shrouded assailant. Once it is concluded, the socio-political issues of the 1960’s through the 1980’s are front and center in Watchmen, creating its back drop, historical references and subtext. Of particular note is the threat of nuclear war and M.A.D. (Mutually Assured Destruction), a lingering and inciting situation that becomes integral to the plot of the film.

Watchmen will inevitably be compared to The Dark Knight because of the overt and subtle pains taken to make both films as reality-based as possible within their divergent universes. Both films delve into the inner workings of their characters but The Dark Knight’s tone never deviates as it does in Watchmen (the sex scene within Owl ship Archie) here and there. Also, the characters, whether villain and hero in The Dark Knight, are not imbued with abilities they did not possess in their comic books. Actually, Bruce Wayne is less intelligent than in the comic book. In Watchmen, characters are abnormally resilient for ordinary human beings and some seem to be in possession of Blonsky’s Super Soldier Serum or Bane’s Venom.

If you have read the Watchmen 12-issue comic book series you know that none of the superheroes, save for Dr. Manhattan, have superpowers. In the film, Watchmen Ozymandias / Adrian Veidt (Matthew Goode) has no visible muscle development once-so-ever (save for a muscle-molded rubber suit) yet is able to achieve feats of strength that his lanky, thin body could not possibly accomplish. Then there is the jumping and the uncanny ability for a Watchmen to get up after getting kicked into inanimate objects, thrown onto the floor or pummeled in the face and body as though they had only been ever-so-gently swatted with flowers. They do not walk with a limp afterward, hold their ribs, nothing. Very strange since none of them have accelerated healing or invulnerability. This is not Watchmen as originally intended by its creators Alan Moore and Dave Gibbons. This is turning Watchmen from a reality-based work of fiction into an unrealistic cartoon and even worse, something we have seen before.

Of all the questions raised about and during Watchmen, the most pertinent is the one literally spray-painted in the background of the film: “Who watches the Watchmen? This question can be approached both figuratively and literally within Snyder’s Watchmen. Figuratively, it is only the Watchmen’s consciences that act as their moral compass. This is an extreme problem since some of the Watchmen’s consciences have been significantly warped. Approached from the literal standpoint, the Watchmen act with impunity. They are at the top of the food chain. They have no oversight and in the film, virtually no one to answer to. If you have seen Serpico, you know what can happen when authority is not monitored and regulated in some way.

Zack Snyder’s Watchmen is an ambitious film that had big shoes to fill in the wake of The Dark Knight and the great 12-comic Alan Moore and Dave Gibbons created. In many ways, Watchmen will meet expectations fans of the comic books will bring with them into film. Concessions and modifications were made from the source material of Watchmen, as in any adaptation for written word to the screen. In the coming age of realistic super-hero films, Watchmen is at the near top.

Rating: 8.5/10

Soundtrack Review for Watchmen

If you enjoyed this article, subscribe to us by Email or Full RSS Feed to be informed when we post new ones.

  • http://www.movieguys.org/ Jon Stephens

    Have I ever told you I love your reviews Filmbook? You always seem to have a way of picking out details and hidden messages, things that most people would never notice. And you are very thorough.

    There were some issues in the film, as you said, particularly the perceived powers of each individual in the group. Manhattan was the only one of them that had power, and I think Snyder failed in adding an important element of the gn to the film that would’ve helped non fanboys connect to the film a little more. If the “heroes” were all just “average joes” normal people in costumes, it would’ve allowed for the audience to connect to them a little more than they did.

    I am a Watchmen mega-fanboy of nearly 15 years, and I was very pleased with the film, if that means anything to anyone.

    Jon Stephenss last blog post..Lars and the Real Girl – DVD Re-View

  • http://www.movieguys.org Jon Stephens

    Have I ever told you I love your reviews Filmbook? You always seem to have a way of picking out details and hidden messages, things that most people would never notice. And you are very thorough.

    There were some issues in the film, as you said, particularly the perceived powers of each individual in the group. Manhattan was the only one of them that had power, and I think Snyder failed in adding an important element of the gn to the film that would’ve helped non fanboys connect to the film a little more. If the “heroes” were all just “average joes” normal people in costumes, it would’ve allowed for the audience to connect to them a little more than they did.

    I am a Watchmen mega-fanboy of nearly 15 years, and I was very pleased with the film, if that means anything to anyone.

    Jon Stephenss last blog post..Lars and the Real Girl – DVD Re-View

  • http://gritfx.blogspot.com/ Manz

    The only thing I can say about this flick is that I want to watch it to see what Carla Gugino has been up to ;)

    Manzs last blog post..Happy St. Patricks Day!

  • http://gritfx.blogspot.com Manz

    The only thing I can say about this flick is that I want to watch it to see what Carla Gugino has been up to ;)

    Manzs last blog post..Happy St. Patricks Day!

  • http://www.coffeerama.com/ coffee

    my immediate reaction to Watchmen is to feel haunted by the intense style and storyline — haunted in a good way; overall i loved it

  • http://www.coffeerama.com coffee

    my immediate reaction to Watchmen is to feel haunted by the intense style and storyline — haunted in a good way; overall i loved it

  • http://film-book.com/ filmbook

    Thanks for the kind words Jon.

    I’m a fan-boy of the gn for about a year now.

    I have issues with the film, as you can clearly see, but overall I enjoyed it, especially the first 25 minutes or so.

  • http://film-book.com filmbook

    Thanks for the kind words Jon.

    I’m a fan-boy of the gn for about a year now.

    I have issues with the film, as you can clearly see, but overall I enjoyed it, especially the first 25 minutes or so.

  • http://film-book.com/ filmbook

    She’s hot in the film,as usual. Wish we got to see her fight like her daughter in the Watchmen though.

  • http://film-book.com filmbook

    She’s hot in the film,as usual. Wish we got to see her fight like her daughter in the Watchmen though.

  • http://film-book.com/ filmbook

    Snyder sets an effective tone at the beginning of the film. I wish the rest of the film kept it.

  • http://film-book.com filmbook

    Snyder sets an effective tone at the beginning of the film. I wish the rest of the film kept it.

  • http://colemancornerincinema.blogspot.com/ Alexander Coleman

    Very interesting, finely-detailed and thorough review, filmbook. I need to see this. I’ll report back after having done so.

    Alexander Colemans last blog post..My Blueberry Nights (2008)

  • http://colemancornerincinema.blogspot.com Alexander Coleman

    Very interesting, finely-detailed and thorough review, filmbook. I need to see this. I’ll report back after having done so.

    Alexander Colemans last blog post..My Blueberry Nights (2008)

  • http://getafilm.blogspot.com/ Daniel

    A great review indeed. And the superpower thing really struck me. For someone who didn’t read the novel, it was evident to me in the movie that these guys had all kinds of superhuman strength. Kind of takes away from the whole point of their characters.

    Daniels last blog post..Short Cuts: "Baby Fish Mouth! Baby Fish Mouth!"

  • http://getafilm.blogspot.com Daniel

    A great review indeed. And the superpower thing really struck me. For someone who didn’t read the novel, it was evident to me in the movie that these guys had all kinds of superhuman strength. Kind of takes away from the whole point of their characters.

    Daniels last blog post..Short Cuts: "Baby Fish Mouth! Baby Fish Mouth!"

  • http://film-book.com/ filmbook

    Thx Alexander. Looking forward to your review.

  • http://film-book.com filmbook

    Thx Alexander. Looking forward to your review.

  • http://film-book.com/ filmbook

    Thx Daniel.

    I enjoyed watching some of the superstrength moves but it was inappropriate for this movie.

  • http://film-book.com filmbook

    Thx Daniel.

    I enjoyed watching some of the superstrength moves but it was inappropriate for this movie.

  • http://the-bone-breaker.blogspot.com/ thebonebreaker

    Fantastic Review!!

    thebonebreakers last blog post..Race to Witch Mountain

  • http://the-bone-breaker.blogspot.com/ thebonebreaker

    Fantastic Review!!

    thebonebreakers last blog post..Race to Witch Mountain

  • http://film-book.com/ filmbook

    Thx bonebreaker.

  • http://film-book.com filmbook

    Thx bonebreaker.

  • http://www.alexlb.com/ Alex Leeson-Brown

    Thank you for the comment and taking a look at my site.

    I am going to read the graphic novel going to get it this weekend in fact.

    I’m glad twitter is working for me it seems to have had a big affect on my site.

    Thanks again for the comment.

    Alex Leeson-Browns last blog post..Get Smart Review

  • http://www.alexlb.com Alex Leeson-Brown

    Thank you for the comment and taking a look at my site.

    I am going to read the graphic novel going to get it this weekend in fact.

    I’m glad twitter is working for me it seems to have had a big affect on my site.

    Thanks again for the comment.

    Alex Leeson-Browns last blog post..Get Smart Review

  • Joshihno

    Wow – incredible review … late to the party here. I just got around to seeing your link to this from Getafilm.

    As an ardent fan of the original graphic novel, I couldn’t agree more with almost everything you have to say here, but I will stick to a few points:

    – your simple statement at the beginning of “Superhero in Watchmen can easily be construed as an acronym for human being.” gets to the crux of the original story’s tension better than any quick explanation I have read, for people who have seen only movie the film version. That’s just a jumping off point (no pun intended) but your review goes on to highlight where Moore takes that idea, and what intricate subject matters he cloaks inside it.

    – having seen the movie twice on opening weekend, I am embarrassed to say that this did not occur to me: “Snyder uses his camera to capture iconic images from Alan Moore’s 12-part comic series but also, by accident or ingenious design, the comic book industry’s past as well. ” Kudos to you for pointing that out, and kudos to you in general for clarifying what Snyder did right, amongst the things (I think) he did wrong …

    – for example, where you correctly pointed out The Dark Knight’s superiority in not deviating from its core tone; I know everyone is sick of hearing about by it now, but Man I think TDK gets better every time I see it

    – “Figuratively, it is only the Watchmen’s consciences that act as their moral compass. This is an extreme problem since some of the Watchmen’s consciences have been significantly warped.” True, but in the book I thought it served as an interesting counter-point to the real-life path of history and the warped characters involved in making that come true. Not unnecessarily just those involved with Vietnam or the Cold War, but several others to boot; but I digress

    – Your last paragraph is spot on. And despite my issues with the film of Watchmen, I wouldn’t be surprised if it stays at or near the top throughout the duration of “the coming age of realistic super-hero films.”

    Thanks again for such a long and thoughtful review. It was a pleasure to read both as a fan of Watchmen and fan of film discourse.

  • Joshihno

    Wow – incredible review … late to the party here. I just got around to seeing your link to this from Getafilm.

    As an ardent fan of the original graphic novel, I couldn’t agree more with almost everything you have to say here, but I will stick to a few points:

    – your simple statement at the beginning of “Superhero in Watchmen can easily be construed as an acronym for human being.” gets to the crux of the original story’s tension better than any quick explanation I have read, for people who have seen only movie the film version. That’s just a jumping off point (no pun intended) but your review goes on to highlight where Moore takes that idea, and what intricate subject matters he cloaks inside it.

    – having seen the movie twice on opening weekend, I am embarrassed to say that this did not occur to me: “Snyder uses his camera to capture iconic images from Alan Moore’s 12-part comic series but also, by accident or ingenious design, the comic book industry’s past as well. ” Kudos to you for pointing that out, and kudos to you in general for clarifying what Snyder did right, amongst the things (I think) he did wrong …

    – for example, where you correctly pointed out The Dark Knight’s superiority in not deviating from its core tone; I know everyone is sick of hearing about by it now, but Man I think TDK gets better every time I see it

    – “Figuratively, it is only the Watchmen’s consciences that act as their moral compass. This is an extreme problem since some of the Watchmen’s consciences have been significantly warped.” True, but in the book I thought it served as an interesting counter-point to the real-life path of history and the warped characters involved in making that come true. Not unnecessarily just those involved with Vietnam or the Cold War, but several others to boot; but I digress

    – Your last paragraph is spot on. And despite my issues with the film of Watchmen, I wouldn’t be surprised if it stays at or near the top throughout the duration of “the coming age of realistic super-hero films.”

    Thanks again for such a long and thoughtful review. It was a pleasure to read both as a fan of Watchmen and fan of film discourse.

  • http://film-book.com/ filmbook

    Thx for dropping by Joshihno. Getafilm is a great site. It does take a while to get through those reviews and comments.

    Thx for the kind words. It is very gratifying that people are enjoying the review and understanding my point of view.

    I plan on seeing the film twice in theater as well.

    If the rest of Snyder’s film was as good as the opening, he would have had a masterpiece on his hands.

  • http://film-book.com filmbook

    Thx for dropping by Joshihno. Getafilm is a great site. It does take a while to get through those reviews and comments.

    Thx for the kind words. It is very gratifying that people are enjoying the review and understanding my point of view.

    I plan on seeing the film twice in theater as well.

    If the rest of Snyder’s film was as good as the opening, he would have had a masterpiece on his hands.

  • http://film-book.com/ filmbook

    No problem Alex.

    You will not be disappointed in the graphic novel.

    Twitter has had a favorable effect on my site as well.

  • http://film-book.com filmbook

    No problem Alex.

    You will not be disappointed in the graphic novel.

    Twitter has had a favorable effect on my site as well.

  • Vern

    Great comments there. Really well thought-out and strongly argued.

    Cheers for finding me, I’ll certainly be following you from here in.

    Verns last blog post..P2: The New Prologue

  • http://[email protected] Vern

    Great comments there. Really well thought-out and strongly argued.

    Cheers for finding me, I’ll certainly be following you from here in.

    Verns last blog post..P2: The New Prologue

  • http://film-book.com/ filmbook

    Thx. Vern. Many drafts, many drafts.

    “I’ll certainly be following you from here in.’
    Very cool. :)

  • http://film-book.com filmbook

    Thx. Vern. Many drafts, many drafts.

    “I’ll certainly be following you from here in.’
    Very cool. :)

  • Dave

    very good review; I totally agree that the opening scenes over the credits were fantastic; I knew very little about this story before the movie, and after the first 15 minutes, I felt like I already knew so much about the characters and their history; 15 minutes rocketed me through decades of backstory. Unlike some of you who knew the story going in, the “super powers” did not bother me too much. Obviously the characters (sans Dr. Manhattan who had many) had some super strength, recovery ability, speed, and/or jumping/falling skille… but I was still able to see them as more human than super human; they appeared to feel the blows physically on the outside and were certainly all too human on the inside. Some of the scenes were a little excessive on the violence end, but I hear that was truer to the book and is what many people prefer…although the historical timing was a little off, anyone think the “dirty whores” thing was a reference to the Sharon Tate murders?

  • Dave

    very good review; I totally agree that the opening scenes over the credits were fantastic; I knew very little about this story before the movie, and after the first 15 minutes, I felt like I already knew so much about the characters and their history; 15 minutes rocketed me through decades of backstory. Unlike some of you who knew the story going in, the “super powers” did not bother me too much. Obviously the characters (sans Dr. Manhattan who had many) had some super strength, recovery ability, speed, and/or jumping/falling skille… but I was still able to see them as more human than super human; they appeared to feel the blows physically on the outside and were certainly all too human on the inside. Some of the scenes were a little excessive on the violence end, but I hear that was truer to the book and is what many people prefer…although the historical timing was a little off, anyone think the “dirty whores” thing was a reference to the Sharon Tate murders?

  • http://film-book.com/ filmbook

    The excessive violence was not truer to the book at all. There is very little gore in the 12-issue series.

  • http://film-book.com filmbook

    The excessive violence was not truer to the book at all. There is very little gore in the 12-issue series.