Movie Review

Film Review: DUNE: PART TWO (2024) – A Good Movie that’s Impressive at Times; Missing Greatness through Wasted Opportunities

Josh Brolin Dave Bautista Dune Part Two

The Worthless Gurney Halleck vs. Glossu Rabban Fight

Gurney Halleck vs. Glossu Rabban is the most anticipated, worthless, throwaway fight in both of Villeneuve’s Dune films. All of the build-up: “The Harkonnens are brutal!”; all of the hate (Rabban gave Gurney his facial scar); all of the history (Gurney’s sister died in a Harkonnen Pleasure House). Pointless. Worthless. None of it is used in the Gurney vs. Rabban fight à la Luke and Darth Vader’s emotional final confrontation in Star Wars: Episode VI – Return of the Jedi.

Advertisement
 

Your mandate as a Dune: Part Two viewer: Forget about all that.

Just watch Gurney’s indignant march through the battlefield as he approaches Rabban.

Rabban is a zero as a combatant. He has no fighting skills, and he leads an army of fighting men. How does that happen, even in a fake sci-fi universe? How does he have no hand-to-hand combat training when he, and his family, are at war with another family, another house, and have been for generations? How does he have no weapons training when he was born into the aforementioned reality, with assassins around every corner? It makes no sense.

Forget about all that.

Just watch Gurney’s indignant march.

The Gurney vs. Rabban fight is completely anti-climactic and an absolute nothing. It’s a waste of screen time. It would have been better if the screenwriters had left it off-screen, like in the book. At least then, there would be no disappointment (at least not this big of a disappointment). In Dune: Part Two, when the lackluster Gurney vs. Rabban fight quickly happens and concludes, the viewer may place their hand to their head, thinking, “This can’t be real. That is their final battle?”

Just remember what is important about their five-second confrontation, Gurney and Rabban’s storylines, Rabban’s whip (spotlighted numerous times in both films), their dialogue, familial history (and tragedy), and everything else that leads to this sorry, mediocre moment…

Watch. Gurney’s. Indignant. March.

That’s all it boils down to. That’s all it was ever leading to.

The Fruitful Paul Atreides vs. Feyd-Rautha Harkonnen Fight

The fight between Paul Atreides and Feyd-Rautha Harkonnen in Dune: Part Two is very good, exciting, and surprising. Their confrontation is far more violent for a PG-13 film than the viewer may have been expecting. Violence doesn’t always make a battle scene better, but Feyd’s kinetic prowess has been built up during the entire film, as has, to a lesser extent, Paul’s fighting ability, in conjunction with his pugilistic exploits from the first film. Their clash should have been epic, and it is.

At one point, Feyd-Rautha is winning the fight and stops to talk about pets. You’re winning. Why are you stopping to talk about pets? Why give your opponent a break to collect themselves when you have them on the ropes? Why? Hubris and arrogance—the two flaws frequently bestowed upon a villain? Without a doubt. Feyd is no humble killer, and Paul, given the breather, uses it to his ultimate advantage.

Feyd’s defeat is the expected resolution, but the road to it is highly entertaining.

Advertisement
 

FilmBook's Newsletter
Subscribe to FilmBook’s Daily Newsletter for the latest news!
Delivered to Your Inbox
✉️
Previous page 1 2 3 4 5 6Next page

Rollo Tomasi

Rollo Tomasi is a Connecticut-based film critic, TV show critic, news, and editorial writer. He earned an MFA in Fiction from Columbia University and has published more than 700 film, television, short-film, Blu-ray, and 4K Ultra HD reviews. His reviews are published in IMDb's External Reviews, Google News, and Bing News. Previously you could find his work at Empire Movies, Blogcritics, and AltFilmGuide. Now you can find his work at FilmBook.
Back to top button
Share via